Unified Home Remodeling

Steel or Fiberglass Doors: What Door Material is the Best?

Unified Home Remodeling - Call Us At 1-888-631-2131

When selecting a front door, the choice between steel and fiberglass materials isn’t just about style—it’s about balancing cost, maintenance, and long-term benefits. Both options come with their own advantages and considerations, whether you prioritize security, durability, or energy efficiency. This blog will help you make a well-informed decision that fits your home’s needs and suits your personal preferences when choosing steel or fiberglass doors.

Our Expert Comparison of Steel and Fiberglass Doors

1) Visual Appeal: Styling Your Home’s Entrance

Fiberglass Aesthetics: The Art of Wood-Like Elegance

Fiberglass doors offer a versatile look that can mimic various wood grains, providing an elegant appearance without the maintenance required for natural wood. They come in a variety of pre-painted or stained finishes, allowing customization to fit any home’s style. Fiberglass doors can also come smooth if you are not looking for a woodgrain look but still want the other benefits of a fiberglass door. 

Steel Style: Modern and Versatile Designs

Steel doors are not only about strength but also style. In addition to offering versatility and contemporary appeal, they can feature decorative panels and glass inserts and be painted in a variety of colors to complement any architectural style. Steel doors can also be textured to give them a woodgrain look.

2) Built to Last: Comparing Door Durability

Fiberglass Resilience: Weathering the Elements with Ease

Fiberglass is highly durable, resisting warping, denting, and corrosion. It’s an excellent choice for homes in harsh or humid climates. It maintains its integrity and appearance over time without the susceptibility to rust that affects some other materials. If you live near the water, a fiberglass door is your best option. 

Steel Strength: Fortified Security for Your Home

Known for its robust nature, steel provides unmatched security. While it can dent, it’s unlikely to crack and offers excellent resistance to forced entry, making it ideal for homes where security is a primary concern.

3) Care and Upkeep: Ease of Maintenance

Fiberglass Care: Hassle-Free and Low Maintenance

These doors require minimal upkeep; a simple cleaning with mild soap and water is typically sufficient to keep them looking new without the need for frequent repainting or staining.

Steel Upkeep: Managing Durability with Care

Steel doors require some maintenance to maintain their appearance, mainly periodic repainting to prevent rust, especially if the finish is damaged. However, a good steel entry door will have multiple coats of paint as well as protective layers against rust. This makes the door basically maintenance-free, needing just some routine care, which involves simple cleaning and occasional touch-ups.

4) Insulating Your Home: Energy Efficiency Face-Off

Fiberglass Insulation: Superior Energy Performance

Fiberglass doors excel in energy efficiency. Their excellent insulation properties help maintain consistent indoor temperatures and save on energy costs.

Steel Insulation: Effective but Conditional Efficiency

While steel doors are insulated, they can conduct temperatures, which may slightly reduce their efficiency. However, most models now come with foam core insulation to improve their energy performance.

5) Financial Sense: Cost and Value Considerations

Fiberglass Investment: Long-Term Value and Aesthetics 

Although more expensive up front, fiberglass doors can provide significant long-term value through durability, low maintenance, and energy savings. Due to their lasting appeal, they also tend to offer higher resale value.

Steel Savings: Security at an Affordable Price

In general, steel doors are less costly than fiberglass doors and provide substantial security benefits, so they are a great choice for homeowners conscious of cost and safety.

Unified How-To | Choosing the Right Door for Your Home

Choosing the right door involves several factors that go beyond simple aesthetics. Here’s a step-by-step approach to help you select the best door for your needs:

Unified Home Remodeling - Call Us At 1-888-631-2131

Step One: Assess Your Needs

Evaluate what you expect from your door beyond just opening and closing. Consider aspects such as security, weather resistance, energy efficiency, and aesthetic appeal. Think about the climate you live in—is it more prone to harsh weather conditions that might affect certain materials? Understanding your primary needs will guide your choice effectively.

Step Two: Set a Budget

Determine how much you’re willing to invest. Doors come in a wide range of prices influenced by material, design, and special features like enhanced security or energy efficiency technologies. Remember that while a higher upfront cost might seem daunting, it could save money in the long run through lower maintenance costs or energy savings.

Step Three: Choose the Material

  • Wood: Classic, expensive and customizable but requires maintenance to prevent weathering.
  • Fiberglass: Durable, energy-efficient, and low maintenance, mimics the appearance of wood.
  • Steel: Offers the best security and is cost-effective, though it can be prone to rust if not correctly maintained.

Step Four: Consider the Design

Select a style that complements your home’s architectural features. Whether you prefer a traditional look with panels, a modern minimalist design, or something with glass inserts for more natural light, the right design can enhance your home’s curb appeal.

Step Five: Think About Energy Efficiency

Look for doors with good insulation properties—fiberglass and steel are typically better than wood. Check for energy efficiency ratings, such as ENERGY STAR certification, which can help reduce heating and cooling costs.

Step Six: Professional Installation

Have your door installed by professionals to ensure optimal performance and durability. Proper installation is essential to prevent issues such as drafts and uneven closing, which can also affect your door’s longevity and effectiveness.

Once you’ve narrowed down your choices based on these criteria, consider the door’s color and finish, hardware options, and any additional features like smart locks or impact-resistant designs. These elements can add functionality and further customize the door to your needs.

Choosing between steel and fiberglass doors depends on your specific needs, whether you’re prioritizing appearance, durability, maintenance, energy efficiency, or cost. Both materials offer distinct advantages, with fiberglass excelling in aesthetics and low maintenance and steel providing unmatched durability and security. As energy efficiency remains a significant concern for many homeowners, both options present strong benefits, making them suitable for various climates and home styles.

Knock Knock, Your Home is Ready for an Upgrade!

Ready to enhance your home with a new door but unsure which material to choose? Contact Unified Home Remodeling in New York to explore a wide range of high-quality steel and fiberglass doors. You’ll get expert guidance through every step of the selection process, ensuring that you find the perfect fit for your home and your lifestyle. Don’t wait to transform the entrance of your home—contact us today at 888-631-2131 or fill out our online form. for a consultation and see how a new door can improve your home’s functionality and curb appeal.

Request A FREE Estimate

    Scroll to Top