If you’re gathering quotes for a roof replacement, you’ve probably noticed they don’t all look the same. Some come in low, others much higher, and it’s not always clear why. Understanding the real cost of roof replacement on Long Island in 2025 can help you line up bids and see which ones actually cover the work.
In 2025, roof replacement prices on Long Island vary based on your home’s size, the roofing material, and the condition of what’s underneath the shingles. This guide explains the typical price ranges, why estimates differ, and what should be included in a complete roofing quote.
Typical Roof Replacement Cost on Long Island in 2025
Roofing contractors measure projects in “squares.” A square equals 100 square feet of roof surface. If that’s unfamiliar, here’s how to calculate a roofing square and why it matters for your estimate.
On Long Island in 2025, the cost runs about $700 to $1,000 per square, depending on the home type and the materials chosen.
- Smaller homes with basic shingles: around $7,000
- A typical mid-sized home: about $12,000
- Larger or more complex homes: $18,000 to over $30,000
- Metal roofing: often $30,000 or more due to higher labor and material costs
Replacing your roof also adds value to your property. Most homeowners recover 50 to 70 percent of the cost when they sell, since buyers see a new roof as one less future expense.
Why Roof Quotes Don’t All Look the Same
If you’ve ever compared a few roofing estimates side by side, you know they rarely match. Some contractors include every detail, others keep it vague, and the truth is your roof itself plays a big role in the price. Here are a few of the biggest differences homeowners run into:
- Plywood Replacement
When the old shingles come off, sometimes the wood underneath is soft or rotted. If sheets of plywood need to be swapped out, expect another $50 to $75 per sheet.
- Skylights, Chimneys, and Gutters
Roofs with cutouts always cost more. A chimney has to be reflashed so water doesn’t sneak in, skylights take extra work around the frame, and gutters may need to be reset or replaced to fit the new system
- Ventilation, Soffits, and Fascia
Proper ventilation protects your roof over time. Repairs to soffits or fascia can add $1,000 to $2,500
- Layers to Remove
If there’s more than one layer of shingles, contractors must tear them off before installing new ones. Tear-off runs about $1 to $2 per square foot.
- Roof Design and Pitch
Steeper roofs and complex designs take longer to work on and require more safety measures. The more cuts, valleys, or dormers a roof has, the more it will cost.
- Materials
Material choice is a major factor. Three-tab asphalt shingles are the most affordable. Architectural shingles cost more but last longer. Metal roofing is the most expensive but can last 40–70 years.
- Brands
Unified installs shingles from Owens Corning, GAF, and TAMKO, three well-known names in roofing. Each brand offers different product lines. The line you choose affects not just how the roof looks, but also how long it lasts and how much it adds to the estimate.
- Labor
Labor is one of the biggest expenses. On Long Island, it usually makes up 40 to 60 percent of the total cost, or about $200 to $700 per square.
- Cleanup and Disposal
Tearing off old shingles creates a lot of debris. Most estimates add $200 to $500 for cleanup and disposal.
Red Flags in “Too-Low” Estimates
A very low bid may seem like a good deal, but it often means important details are missing. Be cautious if an estimate:
- Doesn’t list underlayment, flashing, or ice and water shield
- Skips tear-off and cleanup charges
- Leaves out permit fees, which can range from $100 to $1,000 depending on the township
- Offers no clear information on warranties
- Demands a large upfront payment before work begins
These are the same issues that often show up in roof renovation mistakes to avoid, and can cost homeowners far more in the long run.
What a Line-Item Estimate Should Look Like
A reliable roofing estimate should be detailed, not vague. It should break costs down so you can compare bids side by side. A thorough estimate usually includes:
- Plywood replacement — $50 to $75 per sheet if needed
- Underlayment and ice/water shield — protective layers that keep water out
- Flashing and vents — $500 to $1,500 depending on roof size and features
- Shingles per square — listed by brand (Owens Corning, GAF, or TAMKO) and type
- Labor — usually 40–60% of the total project cost
- Tear-off and disposal — $1 to $2 per sq. ft. plus $200 to $500 for cleanup
- Permits — $100 to $1,000 depending on township rules
When these details are spelled out, you know exactly what you’re paying for. For homeowners still learning about the process, see our post on what to know before starting a roof replacement.
Pro Tip: If you’re also weighing which company to trust, here’s how to pick the best Long Island roofing company.
How to Compare Roofing Estimates with Confidence
Once you have a few estimates, the next step is comparing them carefully. Look at labor percentages, brand and material details, and whether extras like plywood replacement or cleanup are included. This makes it easier to spot where one contractor is leaving something out or adding unnecessary costs.
To make it simple, download our Roof Estimate Comparison Checklist. It’s designed to help Long Island homeowners line up quotes and quickly see which ones are complete and which ones may be risky.
Roof replacement costs on Long Island generally fall between $8,000 and $15,000. Larger homes, steep roofs, or premium materials can push that number higher, sometimes above $30,000. The final price always comes down to size, labor, materials, and the extras your home requires.
The best way to protect your budget is with a clear, line-by-line estimate. It shows you what’s included, makes comparisons fair, and keeps hidden costs out of the picture.
Talk to Unified About Your Long Island Roof Project
Unified Home Remodeling has installed new roofs across Long Island for decades. We use shingles from GAF, Owens Corning, and TAMKO and provide detailed estimates so you know exactly what’s included before work begins. Our focus is on quality installation, reliable materials, and straightforward pricing. For more details, see our main page on roof replacement in Long Island.
If you’re comparing quotes, start with a contractor you can trust. Contact Unified Home Remodeling at 888-631-2131 or fill out our online form to schedule your free roof replacement estimate.
FAQs About Roof Replacement Cost on Long Island
What is the average roof replacement cost per square on Long Island?
Homeowners can expect to pay $700 to $1,000 per square (100 sq. ft.) in 2025.
How much does labor cost for a roof replacement?
Labor is often 40–60% of the total cost, usually $200–$700 per square.
Do roofers charge extra for removing old shingles?
Yes. Tear-off typically costs $1–$2 per sq. ft., plus $200–$500 for cleanup.
What’s the difference in cost between asphalt and architectural shingles?
Three-tab asphalt shingles are cheaper but wear out faster. Architectural shingles cost more but last longer and hold up better in Long Island weather.
Do gutters need to be replaced with the roof?
Not always. If gutters are in good condition, they can stay. If they’re damaged or misaligned, replacing them during the project saves time later.
Does a roof replacement increase home value?
Yes. A new roof typically recovers 50–70% of its cost at resale and makes a home easier to sell.
Can I finance a roof replacement?
Yes. Many homeowners spread the cost over time. See our guide on how to finance a roof replacement on Long Island.
Is DIY roof replacement worth it?
It might look like a savings, but it usually ends up costing more. Here’s why DIY roof replacement is never worth doing.