A roof on Long Island takes a beating year-round. Between coastal winds, heavy rain, and constant moisture, your shingles have to do more than just look good. The right brand can make the difference between a roof that lasts decades and one that wears out too soon.
Long Island homeowners tend to stick with proven brands. GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, and TAMKO are the asphalt shingles most often chosen for their mix of reliability and style. Each has a solid reputation for performance, warranty coverage, and style options that fit local homes. This guide breaks down what each brand does best so you can make an informed choice before signing your roofing contract.
Comparing the Top Roofing Brands
Each of these manufacturers is a strong choice for Long Island homes, but their shingles differ in performance, warranty coverage, and long-term value. Here’s how they compare at a glance.
| Brand | Overall Strengths | Durability & Wind Rating | Algae Protection | Warranty Overview |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GAF | Reliable and widely available with strong contractor support. | Up to 130 MPH wind rating; unlimited wind-speed warranty (WindProven™) when installed as a complete GAF system. | Up to 25-Year StainGuard Plus™ protection. | Lifetime limited product warranty; enhanced System Plus and Golden Pledge® options through certified installers. |
| Owens Corning | Balanced design, solid performance, and standout color range. | Up to 130 MPH wind rating with reinforced SureNail® Technology. | 10-Year StreakGuard™ algae warranty. | Lifetime limited warranty with 10-year TRU PROtection® coverage; extended coverage through Preferred and Platinum contractors. |
| CertainTeed | Premium construction and upscale finish with heavier shingles. | 110–130 MPH wind rating depending on product line. | 10–15-Year StreakFighter® algae warranty. | Lifetime limited warranty with 10-year SureStart™ coverage; up to 50 years with SureStart PLUS via certified installers. |
| TAMKO | Affordable, easy to install, and strong for the price. | 110 MPH standard; 130–160 MPH with enhanced fastening. | 10-Year algae warranty. | Limited Lifetime warranty with 10-Year Full Start™ coverage; workmanship coverage varies by installer. |
Shingle Brand Highlights and Recommendations
GAF
Best for homeowners who want dependable performance and solid warranty protection that stands behind the product.
GAF is one of the most established names in roofing, known for products that go on cleanly and hold up well over time. The shingles use a design feature called LayerLock Technology, which helps them seal tighter and stay aligned during installation. This makes them easier for crews to work with and less likely to lift in high winds. GAF also offers a wide range of colors and profiles, from classic architectural styles to bold, modern finishes, which helps Long Island homeowners find a look that fits their home.
What Most Long Island Homeowners Choose: Timberline HDZ, and Timberline UHDZ are popular options that combine layered design, durability, and some of the strongest warranty coverage available.
Something to keep in mind: This product has mid-to-high price points compared to other mainstream shingle brands.
Owens Corning
Best for homeowners who want a dependable, attractive roof that’s easy to maintain and built to last.
Owens Corning shingles are known for reliable performance and easy installation. They are built with SureNail Technology, a reinforced nailing strip that helps installers place nails precisely and keep shingles firmly attached during storms. They also have a balanced mix of colors, using granule blends that create soft contrast and depth on the roof. The result is a clean, finished appearance that holds up well in different lighting conditions. The brand is a consistent choice for homeowners and contractors alike.
One trade-off: algae protection doesn’t last as long as some higher-end brands, so color fading can appear sooner in humid areas.
Shingles We Recommend Most: Duration, Oakridge, TruDefinition Designer
And Berkshire. They all provide strong wind resistance, algae protection, and a range of color options for both modern and traditional homes.
CertainTeed
Best for homeowners who want a high-end roof built for decades of wear and weather.
CertainTeed is a reliable option for homeowners who want strength and style together. These shingles are recognized for being heavier shingles that add texture and a high-end look to a roof. Many of its lines include features like ClimateFlex polymer technology, which improves flexibility and impact resistance during installation and throughout the roof’s life. The color blends are carefully layered to create natural shadow lines that mimic slate or wood.
Worth noting: higher material cost and weight can make installation a little slower and more expensive than lighter brands.
Top Picks for Local Homes: Landmark & Landmark PRO are favorites for their strength, visual depth, and extended coverage options.
TAMKO
Best for homeowners who want dependable coverage and protection that fits within a smaller budget.
TAMKO shingles are designed for straightforward installation and strong performance. Their AnchorLock layer reinforcement and Rapid Fire Zone nailing area give installers a larger, more defined target, which makes installation faster and more precise. The Advanced Fusion sealants help the shingles bond quickly, improving wind resistance once the roof is in place. TAMKO also offers a wide color range, including both subtle and high-contrast blends that work well with traditional Long Island homes.
Minor downside: warranty and algae protection are shorter than what some premium brands include.
Best Matches for Long Island Roofs: Tamko Titan XT remains the top choice with its reinforced fastening and high wind resistance.
Manufacturer vs. Workmanship Warranties
Understanding what’s covered under a roofing warranty can save you a lot of frustration later. Many homeowners assume a “lifetime warranty” means full coverage for any issue, but that’s not how it works. There are two main types of protection, and both matter when comparing brands before you sign a roofing contract.
Manufacturer warranties protect against defects in the shingles themselves. That includes problems like premature cracking, granule loss, or separation caused by a production flaw. Brands structure their warranties differently. For example, CertainTeed’s SureStart and GAF’s WindProven coverage offer full replacement during the early years, while Owens Corning and TAMKO offer prorated coverage after a set time.
Workmanship warranties cover installation-related issues, such as leaks or nail placement errors. These are offered by the contractor, not the manufacturer. If a problem stems from improper installation, a workmanship warranty is what protects you, not the manufacturer’s policy.
Certified installers can combine both types of protection under enhanced warranty programs. This means your roof is covered for both materials and labor, sometimes for up to 50 years. Choosing a certified contractor isn’t just about the quality of the install; it also directly affects how much coverage you get on your new roof.
What’s Actually Covered and What Voids a Warranty
Roofing warranties sound great on paper, but it’s important to know what they actually cover. Every brand has its own terms, but most follow the same general rules when it comes to protection, and the same pitfalls that can void it.
What’s Covered:
Manufacturer warranties generally cover material defects. This includes issues like shingle cracking, blistering, or premature granule loss that happen because of how the shingles were made. Some warranties also include labor for a limited time during the first few years, especially through programs like GAF’s WindProven™, Owens Corning’s TRU PROtection®, or CertainTeed’s SureStart™ coverage.
If the shingles fail under normal conditions within the coverage window, the manufacturer will typically pay for replacement materials and part of the labor. In some extended programs, certified contractors can even offer full coverage for both materials and installation.
What’s NOT Covered:
Warranties don’t protect against everything. They won’t cover damage caused by improper installation, severe storms that exceed the rated wind speed, lack of ventilation, or poor maintenance.
For example, if your attic traps moisture or the roof isn’t cleaned periodically, that can shorten the life of the shingles and void the warranty. Using non-approved accessories or mixing brands on one roof system can also affect coverage.
Common Ways Homeowners Accidentally Void a Warranty:
- Failing to register the warranty with the manufacturer.
- Hiring a non-certified installer for an extended warranty package.
- Installing shingles over an existing roof instead of doing a full tear-off.
- Using unapproved underlayment, flashing, or nails.
- Not scheduling regular inspections after major storms.
Pro Tip: It’s worth it to do what you can to extend your roof’s lifespan and get the most of what you paid for. We have compiled a checklist of top roof maintenance tips you can do yourself to extend the life of your roof, save money, and keep your house looking its best here.
Most homeowners don’t lose coverage because of bad shingles! They lose it because of paperwork or installation mistakes. That’s why it’s worth choosing a local and certified roofing contractor who handles warranty registration and follows manufacturer standards from start to finish.
How Certified Installers Extend Warranty Coverage
The roof you choose is only as good as the company that installs it. Most manufacturers limit their strongest warranties to certified contractors who follow specific training and quality standards. Working with a certified installer not only ensures the job is done right but also gives you access to better and longer warranty coverage that is backed directly by the brand.
Unified Home Remodeling holds top certifications from the three biggest names in roofing. These credentials allow us to register warranties that go far beyond the standard protection most homeowners get.
Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Roofing Contractor
As a Platinum Preferred contractor, Unified can offer the Platinum Protection Limited Warranty, Owens Corning’s highest level of coverage. It provides up to 50 years of non-prorated protection on materials and includes workmanship coverage supported by Owens Corning. If an issue ever occurs, both the product and the installation are covered.
GAF Master Elite Roofing Contractor
GAF’s enhanced warranties, such as the Golden Pledge and Silver Pledge, are available only through Master Elite contractors. These programs combine lifetime material protection with up to 25 years of workmanship coverage and include labor and tear-off costs if repairs are required.
TAMKO MasterCraft Pro Certified Roofing Contractor
As a MasterCraft Pro contractor, Unified can offer extended full-start periods on TAMKO roofing systems. This means your materials remain fully covered longer before any prorating begins. It also ensures the entire roof system meets TAMKO’s warranty requirements, keeping your coverage valid for many years.
Every roofing brand has its strengths. CertainTeed stands out for its thicker shingles and refined look. Owens Corning is reliable and widely available, with colors that fit almost any home. GAF remains a favorite for its steady performance and range of styles, while TAMKO keeps things simple with solid protection at a fair price.
The right choice depends on your home, budget, and how long you plan to stay there. What matters most is working with a team that installs these products the way they’re meant to be installed, with the training, materials, and care that protect your investment.
Your Roof Deserves Certified Installation.
The best roof isn’t just about the shingles you choose. It’s about choosing the right contractor to install them and how your warranty protects that investment.
With our manufacturer certifications, Unified Home Remodeling installs GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, and TAMKO roofing systems in Baldwin, Westchester, Brooklyn, Patchogue, and other Long Island neighborhoods. That means every roof we install qualifies for stronger, longer-lasting protection backed by the brand itself.
If you’re planning a roof replacement, reach out for a free estimate. We’ll help you compare brands, explain warranties, financing, and design choices for your home. Call 888-631-2131 or fill out our online form to schedule your free consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
How long does a roof last on Long Island?
Most Long Island roofs last 25 to 50 years, depending on the shingle brand and how well it’s installed. GAF, Owens Corning, and CertainTeed shingles often last on the higher end when paired with certified installation and regular maintenance.
-
Do I need algae-resistant shingles in Long Island’s climate?
Yes. Long Island’s humidity encourages algae growth, which causes dark streaks on shingles. Algae-resistant shingles contain copper-infused granules that prevent staining and keep the roof looking clean longer.
-
Is a lifetime shingle warranty really worth it?
It usually is. A lifetime warranty covers material defects for as long as you own your home, and certified contractors can extend that coverage to include workmanship and labor. Shorter warranties often lose full coverage after the first few years.
-
Do I need to register my roofing warranty after installation?
Yes. Most manufacturers require registration within 30 to 60 days to activate coverage. Certified contractors like Unified handle that paperwork for you so your warranty starts right away and stays valid.
-
What can void a roofing warranty?
Improper installation, poor ventilation, or using non-approved materials can void coverage. Skipping maintenance or installing a second layer of shingles can also cause issues. Certified contractors ensure every step meets manufacturer requirements so your warranty remains in place.
-
Can I transfer a roof warranty to a new homeowner?
Most manufacturer warranties are transferable from one homeowner to the next. It’s a selling advantage because buyers know the roof is still protected under the brand’s coverage.